Best Boot Gaiters for Snow and Mud

The pick: Outdoor Research Crocodile Gaiters

Buy the Outdoor Research Crocodile Gaiters if you work outside in deep snow, slush or mud and wear lace-up work boots. The upper is 3-layer GORE-TEX, a waterproof, breathable membrane. The foot panel is 1,000-denier CORDURA nylon, the part that takes the scuffing from rebar, brush and rock. The instep strap is a replaceable TPU strap with internal length adjustment. Retail listings put it at about $110.

Get Outdoor Research Crocodile Gaiters

It wins on four counts that matter on a job site: height, a fully waterproof upper, a tough foot panel and a big top opening. The front closes with double-stitched hook-and-loop, and a lace hook clips to your boot laces. The maker lists the men’s pair at 11.11 ounces (315 g) and covers it under its Infinite Guarantee.

Do not buy it if you work through hot, wet summers in brush and mud with no snow. A knee-high GORE-TEX gaiter is more than that job needs, and the Outdoor Research Rocky Mountain High Gaiters cost less, though Outdoor Research now lists the Rocky Mountain High Gaiter II in their place. Skip it too if you wear bulky insulated pac boots. Outdoor Research says the Expedition Crocodile’s large circumference is roomy enough for plastic boots and heavily insulated pants. Outdoor Research no longer lists this Expedition Crocodile; its current model is the Expedition Crocodile Classic Gaiter.

Get Outdoor Research Expedition Crocodile Get Outdoor Research Rocky Mountain High Gaiters

These picks were not tested. They are ranked on what the makers publish (height, fabric, closure and strap material) and on typical retail prices. No pick gets a score.

The rest, ranked, and who should buy each instead

2. Outdoor Research Expedition Crocodile: for pac boots and insulated bibs. The Outdoor Research Expedition Crocodile gaiters are, in Outdoor Research’s words, designed like its Crocodile gaiters “but featuring thicker materials.” The upper is 70-denier 3-layer GORE-TEX and the foot panel is 1,000-denier CORDURA. On the inside sits a 420-denier PU-coated packcloth lining, which Outdoor Research says is for breathability; it credits the CORDURA shell with crampon abrasion resistance. The maker says its large circumference is roomy enough for plastic boots and heavily insulated pants. The listed weight is 5.3 ounces (150 g), and retail listings put it at about $115. Choose it over the standard Crocodile if you wear rubber-bottom pac boots or snowmobile boots, or kick crampons and spikes into the gaiter.

3. Outdoor Research Rocky Mountain High Gaiters: for mud and brush on a budget. The Outdoor Research Rocky Mountain High Gaiters are 420-denier nylon packcloth. Outdoor Research lists the packcloth with a PU coating and rates the gaiters water-resistant, not waterproof. It closes with a hook-and-loop front and a buckle at the top. A Hypalon instep strap, reinforced boot lace hooks and an elastic bottom edge hold it to the boot. At about $65 it is the one to buy for spring mud, wet brush and fence-line work. On those jobs your boots, not the gaiter, keep the water out. In standing slush, keep in mind that Outdoor Research rates this gaiter water-resistant and the GORE-TEX Crocodile waterproof.

4. Hillsound Armadillo LT: for a zipper instead of hook-and-loop. Hillsound’s page lists the Armadillo LT as unavailable in every size and “Coming back soon with material upgrades.” The Hillsound Armadillo LT has an upper of Flexia 3.0, a three-layer breathable fabric Hillsound lists as waterproof up to 20,000 mm, and a 1,000-denier nylon lower cuff. Instead of hook-and-loop it closes with a YKK waterproof zipper that runs top-down, with a hook-and-loop strap to cover the zipper. The instep strap is TPU-coated nylon and can be replaced. Hillsound sizes the height with the gaiter: 12 inches (XS), 15.25 inches (S), 15.5 inches (M) and 17 inches (L and XL). Retail listings put it at about $80. Buy it if you want a sleeker gaiter that does not snag on brush and you take it off only once a day. Hook-and-loop is faster with gloves on, and a zipper packed with ice or grit is harder to work.

Get Hillsound Armadillo LT

5. Kahtoola LEVAgaiter Tall: for the lightest waterproof pair. Kahtoola now sells the LEVAgaiter Tall only as past-season inventory, at a reduced price while supplies last; its current LEVAgaiter GTX is a 7-inch gaiter. Kahtoola lists the Tall at 13.5 inches (34 cm). It uses a three-layer GORE-TEX laminate with 100% polyester face and backer fabric and a DWR treatment. The listed pair weight is 4.59 ounces (130 g) in size M. That is lighter than any other gaiter here. It closes with a YKK AquaGuard coil zipper. The DuraLink TPU instep strap is replaceable and carries Kahtoola’s 1,000-mile warranty. The gaiter itself has a 1-year warranty. Buy it for winter snowshoeing or hiking on survey and inspection routes, where you carry it all day. Do not buy it for knee-deep snow: Kahtoola lists it at 13.5 inches, and the light face fabric is not built for 1,000-denier abrasion work.

Get Kahtoola LEVAgaiter Tall

Height and fabric: what actually keeps snow and mud out

Height decides how deep you can wade before snow falls in over the top. A knee-high gaiter handles post-holing through unpacked snow. A mid-calf gaiter keeps out kicked-up slush and mud splash but not deep snow. Measure from the floor to just below your kneecap while wearing your work boots. A gaiter taller than that bunches behind the knee every time you kneel or crouch.

Fabric decides whether water comes through the gaiter itself. GORE-TEX 3L (Crocodile, Expedition Crocodile, LEVAgaiter) is a laminate with a membrane, and Hillsound lists Flexia 3.0 as a three-layer breathable fabric, waterproof up to 20,000 mm. Their makers list them as waterproof and breathable. Coated 420-denier packcloth (Rocky Mountain High) sheds splash and light snow, but the makers list it as water-resistant only.

Denier figures tell you how well the lower panel stands up to wear. The 1,000-denier foot panels on the Crocodile and Armadillo LT are roughly two and a half times the yarn weight of the 420-denier packcloth. That lower panel takes the wear from boot-to-boot contact, kneeling on gravel and dragging through brambles. None of these five makers lists a flame-resistant rating, so do not rely on them for welding or cutting work where sparks land on the lower leg.

Fitting gaiters over work boots

Three parts hold a gaiter to a boot: the instep strap, the lace hook and the elastic bottom edge. The instep strap runs under the boot, in the gap between heel and sole. That is why the strap’s material matters. TPU (Crocodile, LEVAgaiter), Hypalon (Rocky Mountain High) and TPU-coated nylon (Armadillo LT) straps resist the cutting and abrasion of walking on gravel and concrete. Plain nylon webbing straps on unbranded gaiters wear through first. Hillsound and Kahtoola both list their straps as replaceable.

Wedge-sole and flat-sole work boots, the style with no separate heel, give the strap nowhere to sit. It slides toward the toe and wears through faster. If you wear wedge soles, expect to replace straps more often or run the strap tighter. A boot with a defined heel of about 1 inch holds the strap in place.

The lace hook needs laces to grab. Pull-on boots such as Wellingtons and most rubber pac boots have none. Without it, the front of the gaiter rides up as you walk. For pull-on boots, size by top circumference and rely on the instep strap and the elastic edge. Outdoor Research says the Expedition Crocodile’s large circumference is roomy enough for plastic boots and heavily insulated pants.

If your boots already pinch or your feet ache by afternoon, a gaiter will not fix it. The fit inside the boot comes first, and the work boot insole guide covers that part.

Hook-and-loop vs zipper closures

Hook-and-loop fronts (Crocodile, Expedition Crocodile, Rocky Mountain High) open the full height in one pull. You can work them in insulated gloves, and you can put the gaiter on without taking your boots off. The double-stitched strip on the Crocodile is the part Outdoor Research reinforces, because that is where these gaiters wear out. Grit, burrs and wood fibre lodge in the hooks and weaken the grip over a season, so brush the hooks out.

Zippers (Armadillo LT, LEVAgaiter) seal neater and catch less brush. Hillsound calls the Armadillo LT’s YKK zipper waterproof, and Kahtoola calls the LEVAgaiter’s YKK AquaGuard coil zipper a “secure, water-resistant closure.” Hillsound adds a Velcro strap to tuck its zipper away. The trade-off is that a zipper can freeze shut or jam with mud, and a broken slider usually means a repair rather than a quick swap. If you put gaiters on and take them off several times a shift, between the truck, the site and the shop, buy hook-and-loop.

Upkeep, and what is not worth the money

Rinse mud off before it dries. Dried clay grinds into the face fabric and packs into hook-and-loop and zipper teeth. Kahtoola’s care instructions for the LEVAgaiter say to machine wash cold on delicate, not to bleach or use fabric softeners, to tumble dry low, and not to iron or dry clean. Membrane gaiters shed water through a DWR (durable water repellent) finish on the face. When the face fabric starts to darken and soak instead of beading water, a wash-in or spray-on DWR treatment restores it. The membrane underneath still blocks water, but a soaked face stops sweat from getting out.

Inspect the instep strap every few weeks. It is the part that fails first, and a gaiter with a broken strap rides up and lets snow in at the boot. Strap replacement is a few dollars against the price of the gaiter. That is a real reason to prefer the Armadillo LT and LEVAgaiter, whose makers list replaceable straps, over gaiters with sewn-in straps.

Not worth the money: ankle-height trail gaiters for snow work. They are built to keep trail grit out of running shoes and sit below the top of an 8-inch work boot. Also skip unbranded gaiters that list a denier figure with no stated membrane. 600D Oxford cloth with a PU coating is water-resistant at best, and the listings rarely state strap material or top circumference. For mud and brush only, the Rocky Mountain High at about $65 covers the job. For snow, buy a GORE-TEX gaiter of at least 16 inches once rather than replacing a cheap pair every winter.

FAQ

Do I need waterproof gaiters if my work boots are already waterproof?

Yes, for snow deeper than your boot shaft. A waterproof 8-inch boot still fills from the top when you step into 12 inches of snow. A knee-high gaiter such as the Crocodile closes that gap. For mud and splash below the boot top, a water-resistant gaiter like the Rocky Mountain High is enough.

Will boot gaiters fit over insulated pac boots or rubber boots?

Only gaiters with a large top opening and no reliance on a lace hook. Outdoor Research says the Expedition Crocodile’s large circumference is roomy enough for plastic boots and heavily insulated pants. Pull-on boots have no laces, so the instep strap and elastic edge do all the holding.

How tall should snow gaiters be?

Knee height, up to 17 inches on the Armadillo LT here (sizes L and XL), for walking through unpacked snow. Mid-calf gaiters, such as the 13.5-inch LEVAgaiter Tall, suit packed trails and slush. Measure from the floor to just below your kneecap with your boots on, so the gaiter does not bunch when you kneel.