Best Fleece Jackets for Work Layering

Top pick: Helly Hansen Oxford Fleece Jacket

If you need one fleece to wear under a work jacket, buy the Helly Hansen Oxford Fleece Jacket. Helly Hansen publishes its fabric weight, it has three zipped pockets, and it is cut to wear under a shell. It costs far less than the premium fleeces.

Get Helly Hansen Oxford Fleece Jacket

We judged the picks on six things: fabric weight in grams per square metre, fit under a shell or work jacket, how well the outer fabric stands up to rubbing, pockets, full zip or quarter zip, and price. We have not tested these jackets. The judgments come from the makers’ specifications and retailer listings.

Helly Hansen’s workwear listings describe the Oxford (style 72026) as 100% polyester Polartec fleece at 251 g/m². That is about halfway between the common 200- and 300-weight fleece classes. It is warm enough to wear alone on a cool morning and thin enough to zip a shell over without the sleeves binding. It has a zipped chest pocket and two zipped handwarmer pockets, all on YKK zippers. A chin guard covers the zip pull when the jacket is zipped to the top. It comes in XS to 4XL in dark grey, navy and black, and Helly Hansen’s US workwear store lists it at $95.

Who should not buy it: anyone who wants a loose cut to pull over a hooded sweatshirt (the Carhartt below has more room), and anyone who welds, cuts or does other hot work, because polyester fleece melts. It beats the cheaper Columbia on one point: the zipped chest pocket holds a phone or tape measure when you bend over.

For room to move: Carhartt Edmonton Full Zip Fleece Jacket

Buy the Carhartt Edmonton Full Zip Fleece Jacket if you want a looser cut than the Oxford or need a tall length. Carhartt sells it as style 106416, also listed as the Full-Zip Relaxed Fit Fleece Jacket. It has a 1 Warm Rating, the lightest step on Carhartt’s warmth scale. It comes in Regular S to 3XL and Tall L to 3XL, and Carhartt’s own store lists it at about $95-105 depending on size.

Get Carhartt Edmonton Full Zip Fleece Jacket

Carhartt’s spec sheet for the corporate version of the same style, CT106416, lists 7.3-ounce, 100% polyester textured fleece. Carhartt states the fabric as 7.3-ounce and gives no grams-per-square-metre figure. The differences are the cut and the outer fabric. Carhartt says its relaxed fit is easy to layer. Carhartt describes the fabric as soft, textured fleece.

The retail listing gives a mock-neck collar with a full-length zip, elastic cuffs, two lower front pockets, and a droptail hem with an adjustable drawcord. Droptail means the back hangs lower than the front, which helps cover the gap above a tool belt when you bend.

Who should not buy it: anyone whose outer layer is a regular- or slim-fit softshell in their normal size. Under a fitted shell, a relaxed-fit fleece bunches at the waist and elbows. Either buy the shell one size up or choose the Oxford.

Lowest cost: Columbia Steens Mountain 2.0 Full Zip

The Columbia Steens Mountain 2.0 Full Zip is the cheapest jacket here that still covers the basics. Columbia lists it as 100% polyester MTR filament fleece in a regular fit, with two zippered hand pockets and an adjustable hem with an inside drawcord. The list price is $65. Columbia sells it in regular sizes S to XXL and in Tall sizes LT to 5XT.

Get Columbia Steens Mountain 2.0 Full Zip

For the lower price you give up the chest pocket: Columbia lists only zippered hand pockets. Columbia gives the fleece weight as 250 gsm. The drawcord hem is useful under a shell, though. Pulled tight, it stops the fleece riding up out of the coat when you reach overhead to hang drywall or pull wire.

Buy it over the Oxford as a spare to keep behind the truck seat, or to kit out a crew when some jackets will be lost or ruined each season. Skip it if you carry a phone or notebook on your chest all day. With only hand pockets, anything you carry sits under the coat’s own pockets and a tool belt.

For the office side of the job: Patagonia Better Sweater

The Patagonia Better Sweater suits an estimator, superintendent or inspector who moves between the site trailer and client meetings. Patagonia makes it from 100% recycled polyester, as a sweater-knit fleece, and gives it a full zip and a stand-up collar. Patagonia lists the men’s full zip at 638 g (22.5 oz). It lists at $169, or $149 for the Patagonia Better Sweater 1/4-Zip pullover. Under Patagonia’s Ironclad Guarantee, a product that does not perform to the buyer’s satisfaction can be returned for a repair, replacement or refund; damage due to wear and tear is repaired at a reasonable charge.

Get Patagonia Better Sweater Get Patagonia Better Sweater 1/4-Zip

It is not worth the money as a jobsite layer. The sweater-knit outside is what makes it look like a sweater, and Patagonia says knitted garments are prone to pilling and this style is no exception. Under a shell all day, nobody sees that outside. The extra $74 over the Oxford buys nothing you use, and the knit’s loops catch on rebar ties, brush and splintered lumber in a way a brushed pile does not.

Fabric weight and fit under a work jacket

Fleece is sold in rough weight classes, usually written as 100, 200 and 300 weight, and the numbers loosely track grams per square metre. A 100-weight fleece is a thin layer for hard work in the cold. A 300-weight fleece is bulky enough to wear on its own. All four makers publish a fabric figure: Helly Hansen gives 251 g/m² for the Oxford, Columbia gives 250 gsm for the Steens Mountain 2.0, Carhartt gives 7.3-ounce fleece for style 106416, and Patagonia gives 10-oz knit fleece for the Better Sweater body. The Oxford and the Steens Mountain 2.0 both weigh about 250 g/m², the right weight for a single fleece that goes under a shell in winter and is worn alone in spring and fall.

JacketFabric (maker’s listing)Published weightCutSizesList price
Helly Hansen Oxford (72026)100% polyester Polartec fleece251 g/m²Not statedXS to 4XL$95
Carhartt Edmonton (106416)100% polyester textured fleece7.3-ounceRelaxedRegular S to 3XL, Tall L to 3XLAbout $95-105
Columbia Steens Mountain 2.0100% polyester MTR filament fleece250 gsmRegularRegular S to XXL, Tall LT to 5XT$65
Patagonia Better Sweater100% recycled polyester sweater-knit fleece10-oz body fabric; garment 638 g (22.5 oz)RegularXS to 3XL$169

Patagonia gives the Better Sweater body as 10-oz knit fleece and the whole jacket as 638 g (22.5 oz); the jacket figure is the weight of the garment, not of the fabric, so you cannot compare it with a g/m² figure.

Fit under a shell depends on the coat as much as the fleece. Put the fleece on and zip it, put the coat over it, and reach both arms straight up. If the fleece hem pulls out from under the coat, or the sleeves bunch at the elbow, the pair is too tight. A regular-fit fleece such as the Steens Mountain suits a coat bought in your normal size. A relaxed-fit fleece such as the Carhartt usually needs the coat one size up. If you are still choosing the coat, our winter work jacket picks cover the shells and insulated coats that go over a fleece.

Full zip or quarter zip, and the details that matter under a coat

All four main picks are full zips, which is the right default for site work. A full zip comes off without going over your head, so your hard hat, safety glasses and hearing protection stay on. It also opens all the way to let heat out during a heavy carry. A quarter zip such as the Patagonia Better Sweater 1/4-Zip has no zip down the whole front, so it lies flatter under a harness chest strap or the bib of overalls. It also costs less: $149, against $169 for the full-zip Better Sweater. The trade-off is that it has to come off over your head.

The small details decide comfort under a coat:

Abrasion, wind and hot work: what fleece cannot do

None of these makers publishes an abrasion figure for these fabrics, such as a Martindale cycle count, so the outer fabric’s construction decides it. Patagonia says knitted garments are prone to pilling, and the Better Sweater is no exception. Whichever you buy, the shell over it takes most of the wear. A fleece worn on its own against a ladder rail or tailgate pills at the forearms and hips.

Plain polyester fleece is mostly trapped air, which is why it is warm and why wind goes straight through it. None of these four has a windproof membrane. Polartec makes membrane fabrics such as Windbloc for that job, but the Oxford’s listing describes ordinary Polartec fleece, not a membrane fabric. On a windy roof or an open slab, plan on a shell over any of these.

All four jackets are 100% polyester. Polyester is not flame resistant: it melts and drips when it catches fire. For welding, cutting, grinding near sparks, or work with an arc-flash hazard, wear clothing labelled to NFPA 2112 or with an arc rating under NFPA 70E. Do not wear a polyester fleece underneath it, because NFPA 70E does not allow meltable fibres such as polyester as an underlayer.

FAQ

What fabric weight should a work fleece be?

For one fleece that goes under a shell in winter and is worn alone in spring and fall, look for about 200-300 g/m². The Helly Hansen Oxford at 251 g/m² and the Columbia Steens Mountain 2.0 at 250 gsm are both in that range; Carhartt gives the 106416 as 7.3-ounce fleece. A 100-weight fleece suits hard work in the cold under a heavy coat, and a 300-weight fleece is often too bulky to fit under a shell.

Should a fleece for work be full zip or quarter zip?

Full zip for most site work. It comes off without going over your hard hat, glasses and hearing protection, and it opens fully to let heat out. A quarter zip such as the Patagonia Better Sweater 1/4-Zip lies flatter under a harness or bib overalls and costs less, $149 against $169 for the full-zip version.

Can I wear a fleece jacket while welding or under FR clothing?

Not a standard one. The Helly Hansen Oxford, Carhartt Edmonton, Columbia Steens Mountain 2.0 and Patagonia Better Sweater are all 100% polyester, which melts and drips when it catches fire. NFPA 70E does not allow meltable fibres such as polyester as an underlayer under arc-rated clothing. For hot work, choose a fleece labelled flame resistant.