Best Suspenders for Work Pants

The pick: Welch WK-7846X-GC for loaded work pants

Buy the Welch WK-7846X-GC X-Back Work Clip-On Suspender if you wear canvas or denim work pants with loaded pockets and want one pair that settles it. It wins on the five things that decide a work suspender: 2-inch webbing, four-point X-back attachment, heavy-duty steel clips, medium-stretch elastic and, per retailer Ironworker Gear, a choice of 46-inch and 54-inch lengths. Retail listings put it at about $33 for the 46-inch length and about $38 for the 54-inch.

Get Welch WK-7846X-GC X-Back Work Clip-On Suspender

Welch’s listing gives the webbing as 2-inch polyester elastic, 65% polyester and 35% rubber, with medium elasticity. Welch says to hand wash in cold water, hang to dry, wipe metal attachments dry immediately to avoid rusting, and never put the suspenders in the dryer. The hardware is 100% steel: silver-finish sliding size adjusters and heavy-duty clip-on waist attachments that Welch says are made to fasten to jeans and heavy pants. Welch’s listing carries a California Proposition 65 warning: this product can expose you to chemicals including formaldehyde, lead and/or lead compounds, which are known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. The two straps cross at the back in Welch’s X-Back pattern, and each one clips on separately at the back, so you get four grip points on the waistband rather than three. Retailer Ironworker Gear says Welch has made suspenders in Portland, Oregon since 1967, and Perry says Welch is now part of the Perry Products family.

Medium elasticity is why this pair, and not a stiffer one, is the default. Squatting to set a box, kneeling at a footing and reaching overhead all stretch the distance from waistband to shoulder. Webbing with 35% rubber gives that length back and then recovers, so the back of the waistband doesn’t get yanked down and the straps don’t dig into your shoulders. The downside is some bounce when the front pockets carry a heavy tape, a utility knife and a handful of fasteners. That’s the job the Super-Tuff Stuff version below is for.

Who should not buy it: if you are over 6 feet, don’t order the 46-inch. Welch’s size guide gives a 46-inch (Medium) a 36- to 46-inch size range and a 54-inch (X-Large) a 40- to 54-inch range; retailer Ironworker Gear says the 46-inch generally fits people under 6 feet, so taller buyers need the 54-inch. Also skip it if your pants have thin, slick or stretch-knit waistbands. Gator clips hold by biting the fabric, and a light waistband creases and pulls out of the jaw under load where heavy canvas or denim holds. The belt-hook Perry below avoids that problem entirely.

These picks were not tested. They rest on what the makers’ specifications and retail listings show, and every figure on this page is credited to the maker or listing that states it.

The rest, ranked, and who should buy each instead

2. For the heaviest pocket loads. The Welch WK-9600X-GC Super-Tuff Stuff Clip-On Suspender uses the same X-back clip-on layout with stiffer webbing. Welch describes it as 2-inch heavyweight Super-Tuff Stuff polyester elastic with minimal elasticity, gives it the top rating (Best) on its webbing-strength scale, and lists it for farm and ranch work at $37.99 on its own site. Buy it if your pockets are loaded all day, for example a framing hammer in the hammer loop plus full cargo pockets, and the medium-stretch top pick would bounce. Welch says to hand wash in cold water, hang to dry and never put the suspenders in the dryer. Don’t buy it if you bend and kneel constantly: with so little give, set the length with some slack or it will pull on your shoulders every time you squat. Welch’s listing carries a California Proposition 65 warning: this product can expose you to chemicals including formaldehyde, lead and/or lead compounds, which are known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm.

Get Welch WK-9600X-GC Super-Tuff Stuff Clip-On Suspender

3. For buying today at a farm store. The Carhartt A0005523 Utility Rugged Flex Suspender is no longer listed on Carhartt’s US site; retailers still sell it. Carhartt lists it at $27.99. Carhartt describes durable elastic straps with Rugged Flex stretch, heavy-duty metal clips and the Carhartt logo debossed on a top grain leather back patch. It comes in one size fits most, and Carhartt publishes no strap length for it. Your torso length decides whether it fits: at roughly 6 feet or taller, the Welch 54-inch or the Duluth tall pair covers lengths Carhartt doesn’t state.

Get Carhartt A0005523 Utility Rugged Flex Suspender

4. For belt wearers and lightweight pants. The Perry SN200 Original Perry Suspenders hook onto your belt instead of clamping the waistband. Perry lists them at $17.50 in Small 42-inch, Regular 48-inch, Big and Tall 54-inch and Extra Long 60-inch, all handcrafted in the USA. Perry sells them as its 2” Original Perry Suspenders. Because the hooks never touch the pants fabric, these work on stretch-waistband and lightweight pants that clips chew up, and they leave no tooth marks. Don’t buy them if you don’t wear a belt: with no belt there is nothing to hook to. Perry says to hand wash them in warm water with a mild detergent and never dry them in a dryer.

Get Perry SN200 Original Perry Suspenders

5. For tall frames and anyone who hates bounce. The Duluth X-Back Tall Clip Suspenders are made for height. Duluth sizes them for wearers 6’1” to 6’4” and lists them at $26.95. Duluth describes 2-inch-wide polyester straps that won’t stretch and sag, with metal clasps meant for jeans and heavy pants, attached at the front and back. Duluth says the polyester won’t stretch and sag yet lets the suspenders flex freely so you can work without restraint; it publishes no elasticity rating to compare with Welch’s. If you are under 6’1”, this tall pair is the wrong length.

Get Duluth X-Back Tall Clip Suspenders

6. For pants with suspender buttons. The Welch WK-7846X-LEF X-Back Work Button-On Suspender shares the top pick’s Welch style number, WK-7800, and 2-inch X-back layout, but ends in leather tabs that button onto the waistband. Buy it if you keep one or two dedicated pairs of work pants with buttons sewn on. Welch says to hand wash in cold water, hang to dry with the leather pieces and metal attachments wiped dry immediately to avoid discoloration and rusting, and never put the suspenders in the dryer. Don’t buy it if you rotate through a drawer of pants without buttons. Welch’s listing carries a California Proposition 65 warning: this product can expose you to chemicals including formaldehyde, lead and/or lead compounds, which are known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm.

Get Welch WK-7846X-LEF X-Back Work Button-On Suspender

Clip, button or belt hook: how each one holds a loaded waistband

Gator clips are spring-loaded jaws with teeth that grip the waistband. Welch makes them in two grades: heavy-duty clips for jeans and heavy pants, and light-duty clips on its casual line. Welch lists the WK-7846X-GC’s hardware as 100% steel and the WK-9600X-GC’s as 100% polyoxymethylene; Carhartt and Duluth describe metal clips. Clips move between any pants in seconds, and that’s their whole advantage. Their weaknesses are a side load, such as twisting while kneeling, which can peel a clip off the fabric, and teeth that wear the same spot of the waistband every day.

Button-on leather ends loop over buttons sewn to the waistband, one button per leather end. Nothing depends on friction: the leather tab carries the load straight onto the button. The cost is sewing. Every pair of pants needs its own buttons, placed to match the suspender’s front and back spacing. Heavy canvas holds a sewn button better than light poly-cotton.

Belt hooks, as on the Perry SN200, hang the suspender from your belt. The belt holds the pants and the suspender holds the belt, so the waistband fabric carries no point load. The 2-inch strap spreads the weight across your shoulders. The trade-off is that you must wear a belt, and the hook holds only as well as the belt fits in your pant loops. Perry says its suspenders fit most any belt up to 2 inches wide, that 1-1/4 to 1-1/2 inches are the best widths, and that the thicker the belt the better.

Which attachment suits you also depends on the pants. Heavy-duck and denim waistbands take clips well. Lightweight ripstop and stretch waistbands do better with hooks or buttons. If you are choosing pants and suspenders together, the waistband construction in Best Work Pants for Tradesmen decides which attachment will hold.

Strap width, back pattern and how much stretch

Width. For work pants, 2 inches is the width to buy. A wider strap spreads the same load over more shoulder, and every pick here except the Carhartt, whose maker states no width, is 2 inches. A 1-1/2-inch strap puts the same load on less shoulder, though Welch does make 1-1/2-inch work suspenders with heavy-duty clips for jeans or heavy pants. Duluth sells its own Metal Free Side Clip Suspenders at 1-1/2 inches and describes them as dressy support for travel pants, which is the right job for that width.

Back pattern. A Y-back joins at one back attachment point, making three points in all. An X-back clips on at two points in the back, making four. The second back point keeps the rear waistband from folding over under a load and splits the pull between two clips, so it is the better layout for work. Side-clip designs attach at the hips instead of the front and leave the fly area clear. That’s useful under a bib or apron, but they give up the direct front lift that holds up loaded front pockets.

Stretch. The picks here cover the full range. From most stretch to least:

More stretch means more comfort when you bend and more bounce under weight. Less stretch means a steadier hold and a pull on your shoulders when you squat. Pick by your load: light pockets and lots of kneeling call for medium stretch; heavy pockets and mostly standing call for minimal stretch.

Wear. The rubber in elastic webbing is what fails first. A worn strap stops springing back and needs to be shortened at the adjuster to take up the slack. Welch documents steel adjusters and clips on the WK-7846X.

Length, adjusters and fitting for tall frames

Suspender size is the strap length measured from the front attachment point, over the shoulder and past the back cross patch, to the tip of the back attachment. For belt-hook models, Perry’s sizing method is to measure from the bottom of your belt at the front, up over your shoulder, and down to the bottom of your belt at the back. Measure over the clothes you work in, because a heavy coat or hoodie adds length.

Makers publish these lengths:

Adjusters. Welch uses two kinds. Sliding adjusters, fitted on the WK-7846X and WK-9600X, are quick to reset. Toothed adjusters, which Welch uses on some 1-1/2-inch models, clamp onto the webbing so it can’t creep. Whichever you have, set the length while bending, not standing. If the straps are snug when you stand, the waistband gets pulled up hard the first time you squat. Leave enough slack that a full knee bend doesn’t lift the back of your pants.

What is not worth the money, and where suspenders stop

Skip anything narrower than 2 inches for work. The 1-1/4-inch and 1-1/2-inch elastic button suspenders sold for weddings and office wear use light webbing that stretches out quickly under a tape-and-fastener load. Skip metal-free travel suspenders like Duluth’s 1-1/2-inch Metal Free Side Clip model for job-site use. Their plastic hardware is designed to get through airport metal detectors, not to carry a loaded waistband.

Don’t pay extra for stiffness you don’t need. If your pockets hold a phone, a tape and a pencil, the Welch Super-Tuff Stuff at $37.99 buys rigidity you will feel as shoulder pull every time you kneel. The WK-7846X-GC or the Carhartt Rugged Flex is the better spend. If you wear a belt every day, the Perry SN200 at $17.50 does the job at about half the Welch price.

Welch says the WK-9600X-GC’s Super-Tuff Stuff webbing provides support “for the waistline, work gear, and heavy tool belts alike,” and Carhartt sold the A0005523 as “Men’s Suspenders That Clip Onto Your Tool Belt.” Welch makes separate 8-point safety suspenders built on Super-Tuff Stuff webbing, and suspension rigs that attach to the tool belt itself are a different product class. If a framing or electrical belt is what is dragging your pants down, go to Best Tool Belts with Ergonomic Suspenders for Back Pain Relief rather than a stronger pants suspender.

FAQ

Are clip or button suspenders better for work pants?

Clips are better if you switch between several pairs of pants, because heavy-duty gator clips like those on the Welch WK-7846X-GC move between pairs in seconds. Buttons hold better on one dedicated pair, but each pair of pants needs buttons sewn on. Lightweight or stretch waistbands suit belt-hook suspenders like the Perry SN200, which never grip the fabric.

Can I wear work suspenders with a belt?

Yes. Clip-on and button-on suspenders attach to the waistband, so a belt can stay in the loops alongside them. Belt-hook models such as the Perry SN200 Original Perry Suspenders actually require a belt, because they hook over it rather than clipping to the pants.

What suspender length do I need if I’m over 6 feet?

Skip one-size and 46-inch regular lengths. Retailer Ironworker Gear says the Welch 46-inch generally fits people under 6 feet and sells a 54-inch for taller frames. Perry offers 54-inch and 60-inch lengths, and Duluth sizes its X-Back Tall Clip Suspenders for 6’1” to 6’4”. Measure from the front attachment point, over your shoulder, to the back attachment point while wearing your work layers.