Best Work Boots for Ice and Snow

Ice and snow: what the job demands, and the boot to buy

For work on ice and snow, buy the Baffin Ice Monster. Baffin fits it with an IceBite Grip outsole, which it says gives greater slip resistance on ice than conventional rubber, on its Hex-Flex outsole design with a deep, multi-directional lug. It also has a waterproof leather upper with a breathable membrane, a composite safety toe and plate, CSA/ASTM approval and an ESR/EH rating. Baffin gives it a Northern cold comfort rating, which it describes as for diverse cold experiences with wet or icy conditions: comfort during moderate activity from 50°F to 14°F. That covers walking frozen lots, climbing on and off equipment, and working in slush around freezing. These picks were not tested. The ranking comes from makers’ specifications and retail listings.

Get Baffin Ice Monster

The picks were chosen on these points, in this order:

Baffin Ice Monster: best overall for icy jobsites

The Baffin Ice Monster takes the top spot because its maker names an ice outsole for it and pairs that with a waterproof, breathable membrane, a composite safety toe and plate, and a laced upper. Baffin’s spec sheet gives a height of 10.75 inches for a men’s size 10. Baffin lists it as CSA/ASTM approved and ESR/EH rated, with non-metallic hardware, a speed lacing system, a rubber toe guard, an external TPU heel counter and a high-visibility reflective overlay. Baffin’s list price is $336.

Baffin says it tested the sole to CSA Z195-14 for coefficient of friction on quarry tile and stainless steel, wet and dry, at room temperature and in cold conditions. Baffin says the IceBite Grip gives greater slip resistance on ice than conventional rubber.

Warmth comes from Baffin’s Fixed-Fit multi-layer inner boot: a Thermaplush wicking layer, B-Tek Foam lining, B-Tek Heat four-channel hollow-fibre insulation and a fixed frost plate. Baffin’s product page calls it comparable to 400 grams of insulation, while its spec sheet says comparable to 200 grams, so go by the Northern rating: comfort during moderate activity from 50°F to 14°F. It is not a boot for standing on a slab at -10°F.

The same spec sheet gives a pair weight of 7.05 pounds, an external length of 12.75 inches and a forefoot width of 4.5 inches, and Baffin says it fits true to size.

Who should buy something else: anyone standing still for long periods below about 14°F, the bottom of Baffin’s rating for it (see the Baffin Impact below), and drivers and operators who want a lighter boot with a side zip (see the Baffin Ice Hero II).

Get Baffin Impact Get Baffin Ice Hero II

Baffin Impact: for the coldest standing work

The Baffin Impact is the pick for long, low-activity shifts outdoors in extreme cold where the site does not require a protective toe. Baffin lists ice fishing among its recommended uses. Baffin lists no safety toe for it, so it does not belong on a site that requires ASTM F2413 protection. Baffin says the Impact is appropriate for extended periods of time in extreme cold weather, snow and ice-covered environments, where activity level may be low to moderate, and that it has the highest level of cold comfort in the Baffin range. Baffin gives it a Polar cold comfort rating: comfort during moderate activity where temperatures from -49°F to -76°F (-45°C to -60°C) have been experienced. Baffin’s list price is $312.

Baffin names no ice compound for the Impact. It lists a Polar Rubber outsole for grip and longevity at cold temperatures, not IceBite. It is chosen on warmth, so on ice, add a strap-on traction device.

Warmth comes from a removable Comfort-Fit multi-layer inner boot: a Thermaplush wicking layer, B-Tek Foam lining, a double layer of B-Tek Heat hollow-fibre insulation, a vapourized aluminum membrane, PolyWool, Hydromax moisture layering, a DiamondNet wind-resistant layer, a waffle-comb footbed and a double aluminum insole. Baffin sells replacement liners for it.

Baffin’s waterproof class for it is B-Tek Dry Waterproof Base: an Arctic Rubber shell at the base, with a leather and nylon upper, a locking snow collar and a double buckle. Baffin’s specs give a height of 15 inches and a pair weight of 7.42 pounds for a men’s size 9.

Who should not buy it: anyone on a site that requires a safety toe, anyone who walks icy ground for much of the shift, and anyone working hard above freezing, where a liner rated this cold makes feet sweat.

Baffin Ice Hero II: the lighter boot for drivers and operators

The Baffin Ice Hero II is the pick for equipment operators, delivery drivers and anyone in and out of a cab or vehicle all day who still needs a safety toe and ice grip. Baffin designed the Ice Hero II specifically for technical and emergency services, and it has a waterproof side zipper for quick access, with corrosion-resistant lacing for a secure fit. Baffin’s spec sheets give it a pair weight of 6.02 pounds for a men’s size 10, against 7.05 pounds for the Ice Monster in the same size. Baffin’s list price is $348.

It has an IceBite Grip outsole, which Baffin says gives greater slip resistance on ice than conventional rubber, and Baffin says it tested the sole to CSA Z195-14 on quarry tile and stainless steel, wet and dry, at room temperature and in cold conditions. It has a composite safety toe and plate, and Baffin lists it as CSA/ASTM approved and ESR/EH rated.

The upper is waterproof leather with a breathable membrane, and Baffin’s spec sheet gives a height of 10 inches for a men’s size 10. Warmth comes from a Fixed-Fit multi-layer inner boot that Baffin calls comparable to 400 grams of insulation, with a removable thermal insole with an aluminum reflective layer. Baffin gives it a Tundra cold comfort rating: comfort during moderate to high activity where temperatures from 14°F to -22°F have been experienced.

Who should not buy it: anyone who mainly stands still in deep cold, since Baffin’s Tundra rating assumes moderate to high activity.

Muck Arctic Ice Mid: deep snow where no safety toe is required

The Muck Arctic Ice Mid is the pick for farm chores, snow removal, ice fishing and site supervision where the rules do not call for a protective toe. Muck lists no safety toe for it, so it does not belong on a site that requires ASTM F2413 protection. Muck fits it with the Vibram Arctic Grip All Terrain outsole with Vibram’s XS Trek Evo compound, which Muck says gives traction on wet ice, snow, mixed and loose surfaces and hard pack. Muck’s list price is $190.

Get Muck Arctic Ice Mid

Warmth and waterproofing are where it beats the leather boots on this list. Muck’s current product page describes an 8mm neoprene inner boot with fleece lining and gives a comfort range of -40°F to 40°F. Muck calls the boot 100% waterproof, with extended rubber coverage, so there is no leather to soak through. A stretch-fit top-line binding keeps the boot snug to the leg to keep cold air out and warm air in. Muck sells the boot as a 12-inch mid, and its spec table gives a full height of 13 inches.

The trade-offs are fit and heat. A pull-on rubber boot holds the heel less firmly than a laced boot, which matters on ladders and uneven ground. Muck’s own range tops out at 40°F, so this is a boot for deep winter, not shoulder seasons. Muck also sells a 16-inch Arctic Ice Insulated Boot at $210 for deeper snow.

Who should not buy it: anyone on a site that requires a safety toe. Choose the Ice Monster or the Ice Hero II instead, or compare more options on the best steel toe work boots page.

What a slip rating does and does not tell you on ice

The slip-resistance standards on work boot boxes measure grip on lab floors, not on ice. ASTM F2913 is the test method behind the ASTM F3445 slip-resistance specification. It drags the sole across surfaces such as tile and steel with a liquid on them. Baffin’s CSA Z195-14 testing likewise lists quarry tile and stainless steel. A boot can pass those tests and still slide on a frozen puddle. That is why the boots here for walking work also have an ice compound their makers name: IceBite on the Ice Monster and Ice Hero II, and Vibram Arctic Grip on the Muck. Baffin names none for the Impact, which is chosen for standing still.

The makers describe their compounds differently. Baffin says IceBite gives greater slip resistance on ice than conventional rubber. Muck describes Vibram Arctic Grip A.T. as built for wet ice traction. Neither maker claims the sole works like a steel stud on hard black ice. For a steep frozen grade or a sheet of glare ice, add a strap-on traction device with metal studs or coils, and take it off before stepping onto tile, steel decking or ladder rungs.

What is not worth the money: “slip-resistant” kitchen-style work shoes sold as winter boots, and any boot you walk in with only a generic lug sole and no named ice compound, whatever its insulation weight.

Insulation, height and fit for winter boots

Choose insulation by how much you move, not by the lowest temperature on the forecast. Boots with 200 grams of insulation suit active work around freezing. Boots with about 400 grams, like the Ice Hero II, whose liner Baffin calls comparable to 400 grams, cover most mixed winter work. Baffin rates the Ice Monster for moderate activity from 50°F to 14°F. For standing still in deep cold, go colder: Baffin says the Impact is for extended periods in extreme cold where activity may be low to moderate, and Muck gives the Arctic Ice Mid’s 8mm neoprene bootie a comfort range of -40°F to 40°F, though it names no activity level for that range. Buying far more warmth than a job that keeps you walking all day needs pays for sweat, and damp socks then chill the foot faster.

Size winter boots with the socks you will wear. A heavy wool-blend work sock is noticeably thicker than a summer sock, and a boot sized for thin socks squeezes the foot. That restricts circulation and makes cold feet worse, whatever the insulation rating. Try boots on late in the day, when feet are at their largest, and check that you can wiggle your toes freely against the toe cap.

The Ice Monster and Ice Hero II both have composite safety toes and plates. If a membrane boot is your priority, the best waterproof work boots page compares more options.

Dry boots overnight at room temperature or on a low-heat boot dryer. Do not put them against a heater: high heat dries out leather and can weaken the glue holding the sole. Pull the insole, or the Impact’s removable liner, each night so the lining dries too. Do not put conditioner on the Muck’s outsole: Muck warns it may make the sole slick in wet or icy conditions.

FAQ

What is the best work boot for walking on ice?

The Baffin Ice Monster is the best all-round choice. Baffin fits it with an IceBite Grip outsole, which it says gives greater slip resistance on ice than conventional rubber, and the boot also has a composite safety toe and plate, an ESR/EH rating and a waterproof, breathable membrane. Baffin rates it for moderate activity from 50°F down to 14°F. On steep frozen grades or glare ice, add strap-on traction cleats as well.

Is a slip-resistant rating enough for icy jobsites?

No. The ASTM F2913 test behind most slip-resistant claims measures friction on surfaces such as tile and steel, not ice. Look for a sole whose maker names an ice compound or ice technology, such as Vibram Arctic Grip or Baffin IceBite.

How many grams of insulation do I need in work boots for snow?

For active work around freezing, 200 to 400 grams is enough, and 400 grams covers most mixed winter jobs. For standing still well below 0°F, choose a boot its maker rates for low activity in deep cold, such as the Baffin Impact, which Baffin says is for extended periods in extreme cold where activity level may be low to moderate. More insulation than the work needs makes feet sweat, and damp feet get cold.